top of page


161 Second House Road, Montauk, NY 11954
Glasses Icon
Platter Icon
Wine Bucket Icon
Phone Number(631) 668-2877

Evoking that classic summer camp period of the 1950's, Ruschmeyer's in New York State is set on three beautiful acres of lakeside woodlands in Montauk.


The charming, cabin-inspired guest rooms that you will be calling home circle the Magic Garden - a central lawn brimming with hammocks, picnic tables, and grills - all for your use.


Those active couples will love the plethora of activities that are on hand to fill your days with fun and excitement. Take to the waters with paddle boarding. Relax and rejuvenate with yoga. Spend some time just the two of you with some fishing. Enjoy a romantic bike ride through the New York countryside with their complimentary bikes.


Ruschmeyer's has an air of that creative New York flair. You'll be witness to the musical performances, artists-in-residence, and theater which spring to life within the grounds.


Each of the rooms at Ruschmeyer's brings something classic, and unique to your stay. The rooms are tastefully modern, with some of the rooms featuring an outdoor charcoal grill for your own pleasure.


Your nightly rate includes a beautiful complimentary breakfast which is available every morning.


In the evenings, treat yourself to a meal at their very own restaurant - The Smile - with a stunning Mediterranean menu. On the colder nights, enjoy your local produce in the dining room. On those beautiful summers days, enjoy your meal outside in the garden.


Electric Eel is the place to be for those endless nights of classic maritime cocktails, and dancing once you have taken in your romantic dinner as the sun sets.


A beautiful experience in New York that will take you back to the magic of yesteryear without losing the modern amenities that make your stay luxurious.


Classic New York charm is waiting at Ruschmeyer's, and the magic of Montauk is ready to inspire and re-energize.


Dinner is​ available in their restaurant from 6pm - 10pm, Thursday to Sunday


The Lucky 13 Suites has an interior which blends Moroccan rugs, hammocks, and classic cedar planked walls. It's 450 sq. feet of beautifully modern spaces with an outdoor charcoal grill for those romantic moments in the evening.


They are a seasonal hotel, closed in winter. They also offer complimentary bike rentals for guests when you do stay!


There is free in-room wifi, and check in is 4pm, with 11am check out.


- Balcony / Porch

- Outdoor Fire Pit

- Seasonal

- On-Site Dining

- Complimentary Bike Rentals

bottom of page